Barred from Justice: Inside the Collapse of the Lorain County Bar Association

How family ties, financial irregularities, and administrative silence dismantled Lorain County’s legal backbone

May 17, 2025

I. A Silent Shutdown with Deafening Consequences

Thanks for reading Aaron’s Substack! Subscribe for free to receive new posts and support my work.

When the Lorain County Bar Association (LCBA) quietly shuttered its doors in 2024, few understood the scale of what had just happened. Within weeks, phone lines went unanswered, the website vanished, and a legal institution with decades of community presence simply disappeared. It wasn’t until early 2025 that residents and legal professionals learned the real story: a potential financial scandal, family entanglements, and a law enforcement investigation stretching into its second year.

The LCBA had served as the connective tissue between the legal system and the community, offering everything from continuing legal education to lawyer referrals. But by the time investigators from the Ohio Bureau of Criminal Investigation (BCI) took over the case, the damage was done. “We used to rely on them for referrals weekly,” said local attorney Mark Donahue. “Now there’s nothing but confusion. Our clients are the ones suffering.”

II. The Motylewski Entanglement

At the core of the scandal are two names: Jeannie and Michael Motylewski. Jeannie, the Executive Director of the LCBA, and her son Michael, also employed by the association, were terminated after what leadership called “financial irregularities.” Bar President Giovanna Scaletta-Bremke declined to disclose the total financial impact, citing the ongoing investigation. “The Board took swift and necessary action once discrepancies were discovered,” she stated in a 2024 letter to members.

Behind that vague language lies a murkier reality. Internal documents reviewed by this reporter show discrepancies in financial records spanning multiple fiscal years. Sources suggest missing funds may total upwards of $100,000, though no final audit has been made public. “It wasn’t just a few errors—it was systemic,” said a former treasurer who requested anonymity. “And they were the only two with direct access to those accounts.”

III. When the Badge Is Too Close to the Books

The situation escalated when it was revealed that Jeannie Motylewski is married to Lt. Charles Motylewski of the Lorain County Sheriff’s Office, and that Michael is their son. Lt. Motylewski, a longtime road patrol supervisor, was placed on paid administrative leave beginning January 6, 2025. Sheriff Jack Hall explained the move during a press availability: “This is about ensuring an objective investigation. While Lt. Motylewski is not under suspicion, we felt administrative leave was appropriate given the circumstances.”

The optics alone necessitated the action. “You can’t have an officer in uniform supervising patrols when his wife and son are the subject of a financial crime investigation,” said one Sheriff’s Office source. Internal emails confirm that Hall coordinated with legal counsel before taking the step, underscoring the sensitivity. To date, no evidence has been presented connecting Lt. Motylewski to the alleged misconduct.

IV. BCI Steps In: When Local Hands Won’t Touch It

Because the Bar Association’s offices are located in Elyria, the Elyria Police Department initially had jurisdiction. But the involvement of a sheriff’s family prompted an immediate recusal. The case was referred to the Ohio Bureau of Criminal Investigation (BCI), which accepted jurisdiction in late 2024. “It was the right call,” said retired Elyria Chief Duane Whitely. “There were too many potential conflicts.”

BCI spokesperson Steve Irwin confirmed their agents were conducting a full forensic review. “Our financial crimes division is involved. We are examining bank accounts, records of expenditures, and statements from LCBA employees past and present.” As of May 2025, BCI had not announced findings, but multiple sources close to the probe confirmed interviews had been completed and financial forensics were in progress.

V. The Legal Community Left in Limbo

The sudden absence of the LCBA has deeply affected local attorneys. “It was the glue that held the community together,” said civil litigator Michelle Yates. “Now, there’s no one to coordinate CLEs, no referral services, and no communication between the bench and bar.”

The Bar Association also provided a Modest Means referral program for low-income residents, which is now defunct. “We’ve had an uptick in calls from people who can’t find an attorney,” said staff at Legal Aid in Lorain. “Some are showing up at court with printouts from Google, asking if a judge can help them fill out forms.” The vacuum has exposed how fragile legal access can be in mid-sized counties.

VI. A Leadership Vacuum and Failed Resurrection

In an effort to recover, the LCBA Board appointed Laura Lamb as executive director and Margaret O’Bryon as bar counsel in late 2024. But the association never formally reopened. “I visited the Broad Street office twice in February,” said a paralegal from downtown Elyria. “Both times it was locked, dark, and had no signage. Like it had never existed.”

Public records show the phone line was disconnected and the website domain expired in early 2025. “At this point, it’s clear we’re looking at either dissolution or indefinite dormancy,” said one past LCBA president. “Without funding or staff, you can’t even keep the lights on.” No official statement has been issued by the board regarding next steps.

VII. Rebuilding Trust, If It’s Even Possible

The LCBA’s credibility has taken a direct hit, and it may not survive. “Our profession relies on trust and ethical oversight,” said Lorain County Judge Kenneth Robison. “That trust was breached—not only with lawyers but with the community we serve.”

Efforts to rebuild will likely depend on the outcome of BCI’s investigation and whether restitution is possible. “If insurance covers the loss, maybe there’s a future,” said one civil defense attorney. “But if the money’s gone and charges are filed, that’s a scar that won’t heal easily.”

VIII. What Comes Next: Criminal Charges or Civil Recovery?

Prosecutors are said to be awaiting the completion of BCI’s report before considering charges. According to internal correspondence shared with this reporter, potential charges could include grand theft, forgery, and tampering with records. “If even half of what’s alleged is true,” said a former assistant prosecutor, “this will be one of the most serious white-collar cases in the county’s history.”

Civil action is also likely. If the Bar Association’s bonding insurer pays out, they may pursue civil recovery from Jeannie and Michael Motylewski. “This isn’t just about jail time,” said the former board treasurer. “This is about recovering what was stolen from an entire legal community.”

IX. A System Without Its Spine

Without a Bar Association, Lorain County’s legal system has become decentralized and disjointed. “There’s no single body advocating for attorneys or clients,” said legal services coordinator Ben Alvarez. “We’re piecing things together with duct tape.”

Community outreach events, school-based legal education, and pro bono clinics have vanished. “Nobody is coordinating Law Day anymore,” said a high school civics teacher. “The connection between students and the courts is gone.” Even small things—like holiday charity drives and courthouse announcements—have disappeared with the LCBA’s collapse.

X. Final Thought: Collapse Born of Complacency

The Lorain County Bar Association’s downfall wasn’t sudden—it was slow, festering, and overlooked. Multiple individuals with knowledge of LCBA operations noted that Jeannie Motylewski had “no meaningful oversight,” and that routine audits were either skipped or lightly reviewed. “People trusted her. That was the problem,” said a former board member. “No one wanted to rock the boat.”

That misplaced trust—and a reluctance to question those in charge—allowed the irregularities to grow into a scandal that now threatens to permanently destabilize Lorain County’s legal framework. As one judge said bluntly: “The people responsible for connecting the public to justice disconnected the whole system instead.”

Aaron Knapp is the founder of Lorain County Politics Unplugged, a journalist, licensed social worker, and public corruption watchdog based in Lorain, Ohio. He writes about transparency, political retaliation, and systemic failures in local government.

Disclaimer: This report is based on verified public records, firsthand interviews, and official statements. Some individuals quoted requested anonymity due to fear of professional retaliation. All allegations remain under investigation by the Ohio Bureau of Criminal Investigation, and no criminal charges had been filed as of the time of publication.